Lorain Moorehead

Therapy and Consultation

The Podcast

Working With Shame in Therapy: Self-Compassion Strategies From Dr. Chris Germer

Dr. Christopher Germer on Self Careapist Therapist Podcast: Expert Insights and Practical Therapy Skills

Shame often hides behind the presenting problem, and working with shame in therapy starts with noticing it is there. In this episode of Self Careapist Therapist: Expert Insights and Practical Therapy Skills, Dr. Chris Germer, co-developer of the Mindful Self-Compassion program, explains how shame keeps clients stuck and how clinicians can meet it with self-compassion. He draws on his new book, Self-Compassion for Shame: A Step-by-Step Guide to Inner Freedom (Guilford Press, 2026).

Guest: Christopher Germer, PhD, clinical psychologist and part-time Lecturer on Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School

Host: Lorain Moorehead, LCSW, EMDR Certified Consultant, PMH-C

Airs: November 18, 2026

Listen: YouTube

Key Takeaways for Clinicians

  • Shame often sits underneath presentations that won’t budge, such as chronic anger or grief that lingers for years.
  • A 2019 meta-analysis of 25 studies found a moderate association between shame and PTSD symptoms (r = .49).
  • Self-compassion works best as resource building. Practicing it to make shame go away tends to backfire.
  • Most self-compassion is behavioral. For shame tied to trauma, Dr. Germer recommends starting with ordinary self-care behaviors before meditation.

What Is Self-Compassion?

Dr. Germer’s informal definition is treating ourselves, when we suffer, with the kindness and understanding we would offer a good friend. He calls it a U-turn: including ourselves in the circle of compassion. He cited a figure that 78% of people are more compassionate toward others than toward themselves.

The definition used in most research comes from Kristin Neff (2003). It has three components, each set against an opposite. Mindfulness sits opposite over-identification or rumination, and common humanity sits opposite isolation. Self-kindness sits opposite self-criticism. Dr. Germer pointed out that those opposites read like the hallmarks of shame, so Neff’s construct describes the psychological opposite of shame. In a randomized controlled trial, the eight-week Mindful Self-Compassion (MSC) program increased self-compassion compared with a waitlist (Neff & Germer, 2013), and a meta-analysis found a large association between higher self-compassion and lower psychopathology, r = −.54 (MacBeth & Gumley, 2012).

Why Do Humans Feel Shame?

Dr. Germer sees shame as an emotion that kept early human groups together, since people cannot survive alone. Research by Daniel Sznycer and colleagues found that the intensity of shame closely tracks how much others would devalue a person for an act, in samples from three countries (Sznycer et al., 2016). Later work from the same group found that devaluation alone can trigger shame, even without wrongdoing (Robertson et al., 2018).

He separates adaptive shame from maladaptive shame. Adaptive shame stops us when we are harming ourselves or someone else. The shame clinicians usually treat is trait shame, a chronic underlying drumbeat that people carry everywhere. Because trait shame is learned from other people, Dr. Germer describes it as not the client’s fault and still the client’s responsibility, since left alone it interferes with their life and the lives of others.

How Can Therapists Start Working With Shame in Therapy?

Dr. Germer looks for shame inside any difficult emotion that is sticky. Chronic anger may be a courageous response to a harsh inner critic. Long-lasting grief may be self-blame about the relationship with the person who died. In trauma work, a meta-analysis found a moderate association between shame and posttraumatic stress symptoms across 25 studies and 3,663 participants (López-Castro et al., 2019).

His sequence for clinicians:

  1. The therapist gets curious first. With chronic depression or anxiety, ask yourself whether a vein of shame runs through it. Be judicious about asking the client.
  2. Find tolerable language. Words like unworthiness or self-doubt can open a conversation about shame.
  3. The client gets curious. When shame is present and named in a palatable way, clients often find it liberating.
  4. Ask how to care for yourself in the middle of it. This becomes the natural next question.

What Does Self-Compassion for Shame Look Like in Session?

Start with behavior. Dr. Germer says most self-compassion is ordinary behavior, like making a cup of tea or calling a friend, and meditation is the smallest part of it. For shame linked to trauma, he recommends behavioral responses first. A behavior becomes self-compassion when it is done in a moment of shame, as care for oneself.

Mind the intention. Practicing self-compassion to get rid of shame tends to fail. Offering compassion in a moment of shame, without expecting shame to leave, is what lets it loosen. The aim is to touch shame without drowning in it.

Help clients find their own phrases. Ask a struggling client: If someone could whisper something you really need to hear, something that would make you breathe a sigh of relief, what would it be? The test is whether the words let the heart settle. Then the client practices allowing those words in, which can be hard for people who feel unworthy of kindness.

How Does This Work Fit With EMDR and IFS?

EMDR: On the episode, Lorain noted that the negative cognition prompt “What does this say about you?” is often a question about shame. Dr. Germer agreed, because shame is an attack on the sense of self. He recommends front-loading self-compassion and waiting to ask the question until the therapeutic relationship can hold it. He also called self-criticism a pathogenic mechanism across diagnoses, and a systematic review links trait self-criticism to a wide range of disorders (Werner et al., 2019).

IFS: The book’s chapter on parts draws on Internal Family Systems. A parts lens dismantles shame’s global claim that “I am all bad,” and it gives access to young parts that have carried shame in exile for decades. Chronic anger is often a protector. Richard Schwartz once described MSC to Dr. Germer as muscle building and IFS as constraint reducing, and Dr. Germer finds the two work well together.

How Do Core Values Help With Shame?

The central self-compassion question is “What do I need?” Core values reach beyond our own suffering. Dr. Germer asks clients to name the deepest thing: the quality that brings joy and energy when they live close to it and leaves them lost and drained when they drift from it. Values can be lived in small ways even under severe limits. He also cautions that a value that is only a social norm will deplete a person, while a deeply held value energizes them.

Where Can Therapists Learn Self-Compassion for Shame?

About Dr. Chris Germer

Christopher Germer, PhD, is a clinical psychologist and part-time Lecturer on Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School with a small psychotherapy practice in Massachusetts. He co-developed the Mindful Self-Compassion program with Kristin Neff in 2010. MSC has since been taught in more than 30 languages and 60 countries. He co-authored The Mindful Self-Compassion Workbook and Teaching the Mindful Self-Compassion Program with Neff, and he is the author of The Mindful Path to Self-Compassion and Self-Compassion for Shame. His website is chrisgermer.com.

About the Host

Lorain Moorehead, LCSW, is an EMDR Certified Consultant, PMH-C, and clinical supervisor licensed in Arizona and Texas as well as Alaska. She hosts Self Careapist Therapist: Expert Insights and Practical Therapy Skills, a podcast for licensed mental health clinicians.

References

If shame is showing up across your caseload and you want a second set of eyes on a case, see Clinical Consultation and Supervision for Therapists.

Full Episode Transcript

This transcript has been edited lightly for readability. Filler words and false starts were removed.

Introduction and Defining Self-Compassion (00:00)

Lorain Moorehead: Welcome back, Self Careapists. Today we’re going to talk all about why shame keeps clients stuck and how to work with it using self-compassion. I want to welcome Dr. Chris Germer, who co-developed the Mindful Self-Compassion program with Kristin Neff in 2010. His newest book, Self-Compassion for Shame: A Step-by-Step Guide to Inner Freedom, is out on shelves now. Welcome, Dr. Germer.

Dr. Chris Germer: Thanks, Lorain. So glad to be here.

Lorain Moorehead: I’m really glad to have you. For an initial vocabulary, can you define how you look at self-compassion and what it is?

Dr. Chris Germer: There’s an informal definition of self-compassion, which I like and which many people find quite accessible. That is treating ourselves, when we suffer, with the same kindness and understanding as we would treat a good friend, which 78% of us don’t do. In other words, we’re much more compassionate toward others. Self-compassion is basically a U-turn, and it’s a humble enterprise. It’s about just including ourselves in the circle of compassion.

Kristin Neff has a more formal definition, which has been used in most of the research on self-compassion, now over 10,000 studies. She defines self-compassion as having three components: mindfulness versus over-identification or rumination, common humanity versus isolation, and self-kindness versus self-criticism. On the topic of shame, those opposite qualities are hallmarks of shame. So when Kristin defined self-compassion back in 2003, although she was a developmental psychologist and didn’t know anything about shame, she basically came up with a psychological construct which is the opposite of shame. And the research has since shown that. So it’s very convenient.

Lorain Moorehead: That really worked out.

Dr. Chris Germer: I thought so too.

How Shame Hid Behind 22 Years of Anxiety (02:17)

Lorain Moorehead: I first learned about the Mindful Self-Compassion program because I went through the Daring Way facilitator training. I remember taking that quiz of how self-compassionate I am, which is still available. I just checked yesterday. It’s more elaborate than what I recall from the early aughts. I like what you said. It turns out that shame and self-compassion are on two ends of the spectrum. They’re opposites. Can you share what led you down this pathway of exploring shame?

Dr. Chris Germer: My doorway to self-compassion was through shame. I graduated in 1984 with a PhD in clinical psychology and a specialization in anxiety disorders. And then I suffered from public speaking anxiety for the next 22 years, despite doing everything that I knew was good for it, including exposure. In other words, speaking whenever I got a chance. I was also a mindfulness meditator. Nothing worked.

Then, shortly before a big conference at Harvard Medical School, I started to practice loving-kindness meditation for myself. It’s just about being kind to yourself, not to fix anything, but just because you’re struggling. And that was the difference that made a difference. Two things were involved. One was the gift of desperation. I was really ready to try something just to feel better, not to fix public speaking anxiety. The other was the magic of intentionally giving ourselves kindness, this U-turn we were talking about. For the first time in my life, in front of a large group, it made my public speaking anxiety disappear.

The other thing it did is it lowered the volume on what was behind public speaking anxiety, and that was shame. Back in those days, Lorain, this was 2006, so 20 years ago, we didn’t talk too much about shame. We didn’t know that shame is more significant than fear in PTSD. We didn’t know that shame was a key factor in social anxiety and performance anxiety. We just didn’t know. I thought I was suffering from an anxiety problem, but really I was suffering from a shame problem, because I wasn’t afraid of shaking like a leaf or being unable to speak. I was afraid of being judged for shaking like a leaf or being unable to speak. So shame was hiding behind the anxiety, and I just didn’t have a clue.

Loving-kindness meditation for myself, or self-compassion, made the shame manageable enough that I could see what was behind the anxiety. That was fascinating to me as a clinician. I thought, if this has been hiding behind my anxiety for 22 years, and mind you, I was a therapist through those 22 years, I wonder what is the role of shame, and how could self-compassion be helpful to my clients? So it started right with my introduction to self-compassion.

Shame Behind Chronic Anger and Sticky Grief (06:08)

Lorain Moorehead: It’s really interesting to hear you say that for so many of our clients that we have classified in a certain way, shame is worth exploring across so many of the different presentations we might be seeing.

Dr. Chris Germer: For me, shame was running through anxiety, but shame runs through almost every difficult emotion that is really sticky. For example, say you have a client who seems to have chronic anger, angry all the time. We think, why is this person so angry? It’s not good for them. They’re antagonizing other people. It’s bad for their physiology. Don’t be so angry. And we don’t understand where the anger is coming from. If we look for shame, we may even see that the anger is a brave, courageous response to the inner criticism, which is probably far more toxic than what comes out of the person’s mouth.

So often behind chronic anger is shame. Behind chronic sadness is shame. Often, obviously not always, behind really sticky grief is shame. In other words, if somebody passes away and you spend your time thinking about how you were not a good person with that person, then we’re not grieving. We’re just shaming ourselves. And then we wonder why this lingers so long. It’s because we’ve never grieved.

Responding to the Echoes of the Past (07:53)

Lorain Moorehead: It’s interesting to think about it that way too, because keeping it in shame almost feels like something you can hold. Whereas external things like childhood or a death are so far removed from anything we have control over that those feel untouchable.

Dr. Chris Germer: That’s really wise. We often would like to re-parent ourselves. We would like to go back and change the past, but the past is past. It cannot be changed. But we can change our memory of the past. We can change our emotional reactions to the past. And if what’s lingering is shame, and shame is arising in the present moment, then we can do the magical thing of responding to ourselves as we wished we were treated way back when. We can give ourselves the thoughtfulness and the kindness that we probably didn’t receive back then, which is why the shame or trauma is still lingering. Trauma and shame are very closely related.

So we can re-parent ourselves, not by changing the past, but by responding to the echoes of the past with mindfulness and compassion. This is an enormous opportunity. That includes shame that’s been acquired not in childhood but through cultural oppression. We can respond to any internalized shaming messages, even ongoing ones, with compassion, in a way that our hearts get protected in the present and from past memories.

Why Humans Feel Shame (09:49)

Lorain Moorehead: I think this is going to be a really interesting route for us to take. Right before we go there, I thought it was really interesting to imagine the role that shame has for members of a society, why we’ve adapted to have shame in the first place, and some of the functions it has served from the beginning of our culture.

Dr. Chris Germer: The evolutionary value of shame is probably to keep the tribe together so that we can survive, because human beings are social animals. They cannot survive alone in isolation. We need each other. So what does it take to keep us together? If somebody wanders off from the group and jeopardizes their life and the lives of everybody else, you can imagine that tribe members would come and clunk them over the head and drag them back. But shame does that quite naturally.

Shame is interesting. Daniel Sznycer and his colleagues found that shame is not caused by breaking the rules. It’s caused by being devalued by others, often for breaking the rules. When we experience devaluation, it creates a panic response. Shame often feels worse than fear of death. It feels like psychological death, being completely excluded from other human beings. So this is a very intense emotion, which served a survival function. We were all born with the capacity for shame. That’s important to know.

Even today, there’s maladaptive shame and adaptive shame. Adaptive shame means that if we’re doing something harmful to ourselves or others and we feel shame about it, we stop. Shame stops us in our tracks. Sadly, shame doesn’t encourage us to do good things. Guilt does that. But shame stops us in our tracks. We all know any number of people who do terrible things but don’t feel shame about it, so they just keep doing it.

So there is such a thing as adaptive shame, but in clinical work we’re usually dealing with maladaptive shame, unhelpful shame, or what is sometimes called toxic shame, otherwise known as trait shame. That’s the shame we carry around with us everywhere we go. I have a bit of trait shame that came out, in the form of public speaking anxiety, when I stood in front of an audience. It’s a kind of underlying drumbeat that expresses itself in ways that make us afraid or inauthentic or withdrawn. The shame we carry around everywhere is not good for anybody.

But the interesting thing, Lorain, is that shame, though it makes us feel really bad about ourselves, is not our fault, because we learned it in the world. We learned it from other people. So the shame we mostly see in therapy, the trait shame, the chronic shame, is not our fault, but it is our responsibility, because if we don’t do something about it, it’s going to interfere in our own lives and in the lives of others. So it’s good to think about shame as state shame and trait shame, and to know it originally had an evolutionary value.

Lorain Moorehead: That makes a lot of sense. I once made these goggles where I put images on the lenses. Anything I looked at while wearing them, I would see those images. That’s how I think of trait shame. Whatever the thing is that makes you feel less, you’re seeing it everywhere you look.

Dr. Chris Germer: So it’s a frown, it’s a glare, it’s someone pointing critically.

Lorain Moorehead: Being small, staying small.

Dr. Chris Germer: Yes. That’s how a lot of people go through the world. It’s sad.

Self-Compassion as Resource Building (14:32)

Lorain Moorehead: One thing you note in the book is that self-compassion isn’t therapy. It’s resource building.

Dr. Chris Germer: I mentioned this to Esther Perel, and she said, “Well, it’s not traditional therapy, but it is therapy.” And I would agree. The reason we say that is pretty subtle. Earlier I was saying that when I started to practice self-compassion, not to fix myself or reduce my anxiety, but just as an expression of kindness to a wounded person, it worked. Similarly, if we think, “I’m going to practice self-compassion in order to reduce my shame, get rid of my shame,” it’s not going to work.

The idea of therapy is that a person has wounds, which we will heal. But when it comes to self-compassion practice, a more effective approach than focusing on the wound and trying to reduce shame is to say, “I’m going to build the muscle of compassion, and I’m going to give myself compassion in a moment of shame.” When we do it like that, without hoping or expecting that shame will disappear, it will disappear. So the motivation, the intention behind it, makes all the difference in terms of success.

It’s very tricky for therapists. Insurance companies ask what you’re going to do about this person’s anxiety, how much anxiety they have now compared to when they first saw you, and whether it’s less or more. We can think about that. But what we mainly want to be doing is opening to the experience of shame, not completely. We just need to touch shame and be with shame, not in a way that we’re drowning in it, but in a way that cracks our heart open. Then the kindness and the compassion can get in. The medicine can get in.

Helping Clients Recognize Shame (17:05)

Lorain Moorehead: Continuing down that road, do you still have a small private practice?

Dr. Chris Germer: Yes.

Lorain Moorehead: How do you see yourself and others effectively combine mindfulness for shame with therapy? What can clinicians listening keep in mind as they begin to identify shame in their clients more clearly?

Dr. Chris Germer: The first step is to get curious about this. If we have a client with chronic depression or chronic anxiety, we ask ourselves the question. You want to be judicious about asking your client, but ask yourself: Is shame involved? Is there a vein of shame running through this that we don’t see? For example, I have a client who has been profoundly traumatized, and he will say, “When I have flashbacks, the worst part is the shame.”

Lorain Moorehead: Oh, yeah.

Dr. Chris Germer: This is new, because shame, as you said, Lorain, is something you can work with. You can’t change the past, but you can work in the present with shame. So the first thing is for clinicians to get curious about shame. Second is to find a way of talking about shame. You could talk about unworthiness or self-doubt. Then, through an interesting conversation, the client at some point may get curious about shame as well. And if shame is really happening, and it has been named in a way that is palatable, it’s liberating. Our clients will say, “Whoa, I had no idea. I thought I had an anger problem. I realized that whenever I get mad at somebody, I’m feeling shame. I couldn’t stop being angry, but I can be kind to myself when I feel shame.”

So first the therapist gets interested: Is this shame? Then the client gets interested: Is this shame? The next pretty natural response is: How can I care for myself in the midst of shame? There are an infinite number of ways we can be kind to ourselves. Mostly when people think about self-compassion, they think about contemplative practices like meditation, but that’s the least of self-compassion. Most self-compassion is behavioral practice. In other words, ordinary stuff. In a moment of shame, maybe I can have a cup of tea. Maybe I can listen to some music. Maybe I can put my hand over my heart and rub my chest. Maybe I should call a friend. Maybe I should garden.

Many people worry, “If I feel shame, I’m going to get overwhelmed. If I give myself compassion, it’s going to kick up all sorts of old stuff.” That’s all true, but the key thing is how do I respond? Especially when we’re dealing with shame linked to trauma, therapists should think about behavioral responses to shame. So first, can I see shame? And how do I respond?

Behavioral Self-Compassion (20:49)

Lorain Moorehead: That’s a great reminder that a collection of pleasurable activities or behaviors that are true to who your clients are could be so helpful and so accessible. A behavior feels safe to do, whereas going into meditation right off the bat can feel a little jarring for someone.

Dr. Chris Germer: Self-care behaviors are habitual and they’re ordinary, so nobody’s going to be harmed. They’ll be helped. But what makes it self-compassion is this: in a moment of shame, we’re usually pretty harsh with ourselves. We criticize ourselves, we deny ourselves, we abandon ourselves. If we can remember a simple behavioral act, such as listening to some music that I love, in the midst of shame, it will transform the experience of shame. Especially if we do it not to get rid of shame, but just to care for ourselves because we’re feeling shame.

EMDR Negative Cognitions and Shame (22:09)

Lorain Moorehead: And there’s a muscle-building component to these pieces. To your point, it starts with the vocabulary and with recognizing it. I think we can talk about modalities too, because I hear threads of many different therapeutic approaches throughout the book. One that I use is EMDR. Do you use much EMDR?

Dr. Chris Germer: I don’t, but I’m familiar with EMDR.

Lorain Moorehead: One of the elements I think clinicians struggle with is the negative cognition. One of the prompts we sometimes use to whittle down to it is, “What does this situation say about you?” As I’m talking to you and reading the book, we’re really asking, “What’s the shame? Where is the shame in this?”

Dr. Chris Germer: Exactly. Because shame is an attack on the sense of self. So “What does it say about you?” basically means “What does it say about you that’s not good?”

Lorain Moorehead: And sometimes even that premise is revolting to people. They say, “I didn’t do it. This isn’t about me, it’s about so-and-so.” It takes some compassion and whittling to even make that premise tolerable to talk about.

Dr. Chris Germer: Self-criticism in general is self-shaming. And self-criticism is a pathogenic mechanism in just about every psychological diagnosis. We’re doing this all the time, especially when things aren’t going well in our lives. So what is the self-compassionate approach to self-criticism, or to “What does this say about you?” What we really want to do is front-load self-compassion. In other words, a certain kindness and the realization that we come by our self-criticism honestly. We come by any shame honestly, and that is not our fault. But if we can see it, we can be free from it. That doesn’t mean we’re getting rid of it with self-compassion. It means we can meet it with self-compassion, and then it will let us go.

The Therapeutic Relationship as Context (24:32)

Lorain Moorehead: Sometimes even starting at the point where you can be in the room with it, without finding it completely offensive, is a huge starting point.

Dr. Chris Germer: I think, Lorain, that in therapy, good EMDR therapists, surely like yourself, cultivate a compassionate relational environment for the work. I was saying we want to front-load self-compassion, but we also want to make sure we don’t ask these questions until we’re good. These are questions we can ask because we respect each other in the room and we’re working together. In other words, the therapeutic relationship and the therapist’s presence create a context for doing some of the more courageous work of looking at shame.

Using the Book With Clients (25:36)

Lorain Moorehead: We do a lot of resource building. If a therapist is building resources with their client and giving them tools and different exercises to move through, there are a lot of scripts in your book that an individual could use. I think it’s designed for a person going on their own journey, but it can be really helpful with resourcing, helping a client build their resources as well.

Dr. Chris Germer: I really hope that therapists use this book with their clients. The book is a description of an eight-week, 24-hour training program, which is interpersonal. The hard work of writing the book was capturing some of that interpersonal warmth and safety that people feel in relationship with others who care about them. So anybody who uses the book as a stepping stone to do this work with another human being, or more than one, will definitely potentiate it.

Lorain Moorehead: And that’s how some of this started. You’ve been integrating it in a training to build these practices and principles, and now it’s in book form.

Dr. Chris Germer: I think I’ve taught this training maybe 12 or 15 times. Many colleagues have taught it as well, and we’ve been co-developing the program. The practices always get tweaked a little to land in just the right way. But for now, the way they’re written in the book is the best we know at this point about how to cultivate self-care. Self-compassion for shame is a skill. It’s not new. Shame has always been managed by self-compassion, but now we’re doing it explicitly.

Lorain Moorehead: I hadn’t thought about it the way you phrased it, about delivering it with an interpersonal lens. It can feel heavy for folks to start to dig into this, and the interpersonal lens makes a lot of sense.

Dr. Chris Germer: I’m very happy that that was your experience. Thank you.

IFS, Parts Work, and Shame (28:11)

Lorain Moorehead: Another modality I heard woven throughout the work is IFS, or parts work. That’s a modality I use as well, so I was excited to see how you explained it. Can you talk about how IFS or parts work shows up in this work?

Dr. Chris Germer: There’s a chapter on parts psychology, particularly drawn from IFS. Dick Schwartz is a friend of mine, and we’ve done things together. When working with shame, it’s really important to be willing to think about parts, for a few reasons.

One is that shame is a global negative self-evaluation. It means you’re bad. But if you take a parts perspective, there’s no you who is all bad. There could be a part of you that did something wrong, or a part of you carrying a heavy burden that somebody laid on it, even over years. Parts psychology dismantles one of the core ideas of shame, which is “I am all bad.” That’s a beautiful thing from the get-go.

The second thing is that often the burden that keeps parts of us hidden and in exile is shame, because shame is so hard to work with, especially when we’re quite young and don’t have any perspective. We can’t say, “No, this isn’t about me, this is about George.” We just absorb it. So if we’ve been shamed, those parts of us that have been shamed go into hiding and hold it for 50 years, 60 years.

So how do we access that shame? It’s really helpful not to just have the intention to feel shame. It’s helpful to visualize ourselves at a time when the injury occurred and to relate to that part of ourselves in a compassionate way, as well as, frankly, to protectors. Some protectors are pretty fierce, like anger. When I say somebody has chronic anger, that’s basically an overactive protector part doing its darnedest to protect the wounded part. Parts psychology is really useful for accessing shame and also for dismantling the global nature of shame.

For your listeners who are IFS therapists, Dick once said to me, “Chris, self-compassion, like Mindful Self-Compassion, is muscle building, and IFS is constraint reducing.” In IFS, we free parts of ourselves from their burdens. We reduce the constraints so they can be more free. Whereas with MSC, we’re cultivating the resource over and over again. What I’ve found is that all over the world there are many MSC practitioners and teachers who are therapists and also practice IFS, and we find that both are really great. It’s really great to build the muscle of compassion so that when parts of us are difficult to deal with, like angry protectors or hidden, young, vulnerable parts, those parts are more willing to reveal themselves and let go of their hard work when they know that compassion is in the house.

Lorain Moorehead: Definitely. I think Dr. Schwartz would argue that they’re not going to do it at all if there’s not some element of safety or compassion. You can’t coax them into releasing their job without that.

Dr. Chris Germer: They’re too smart.

Lorain Moorehead: They’re sophisticated.

Dr. Chris Germer: They’ve been at it a long time. I’ve noticed that when our hearts are really alive with love, our parts come out even unbidden. It’s like, “Here I am. This is what happened to me.” And then we can respond to that in a caring way. So I find the work so much easier when we cultivate a compassionate heart.

The Lump in the Throat (33:26)

Lorain Moorehead: Just to get a bit granular with the IFS approach, there was a great vignette in the book where a woman shared with you that she was feeling shame like a lump in her throat. There was a block to reducing it. The language you gave was to imagine that part of her body is like a person and has a voice. I thought that was such great language to be able to access in that moment.

Dr. Chris Germer: That’s what got me interested in parts psychology in the first place. This was in a room of about 100 people, and she bravely said, “After this exercise, I have a lump in my throat and it’s not going away.” She was clearly in distress. I said, “Imagine that this lump were a person. What would it want you to know?” And she started to cry. She didn’t share publicly in that setting what it was, but I talked to her shortly afterward, and she said the lump went away. She was greatly relieved, and she learned a lot. So that’s another good example of the power of parts.

Lorain Moorehead: Did you say that to her intuitively? Oh my gosh, that’s something I hear from clients and practitioners alike: in some ways parts work just naturally felt intuitive to them. They can think that way and use the language, or in some ways they always have.

Dr. Chris Germer: To be honest, it may have been in the zeitgeist already, and maybe I had heard something like this somewhere. That’s what came out of my mouth, and I was quite surprised as well, both that it came out and by the response.

Finding Your Own Loving-Kindness Phrases (35:17)

Lorain Moorehead: That it resonated, that she needed to hear it. That’s so interesting. Can you talk a little more about how you use loving-kindness and how to create a phrase?

Dr. Chris Germer: At the time, I used traditional phrases that have been around for about 1,500 years, similar to “May I be safe, may I be peaceful, may I be healthy, may I live with ease.” Ultimately it’s not the words but the tone, or the state of mind, communicated by the words. So in the Mindful Self-Compassion program, and also in the shame book, we invite people to find their own phrases that capture the attitude, the intention, the tone, the spirit of kindness and compassion.

One really easy way to do this, which therapists can do, clients can do, and you could do in therapy, is when a person is really struggling, to ask: If someone were to whisper into your ear right now something you really need to hear, and when you hear it you breathe a sigh of relief and maybe even say, “Oh, thank you, I really needed to hear that,” what would that be? People who are struggling with shame might reflect for a moment and say they would hear something like “You did the best you could,” or “It’s not your fault,” or “You didn’t know,” or “I admire your strength,” or “I’m here for you,” or “I believe in you,” or “I trust you,” or “You are a good person,” or “I love you.” Everybody’s different. It depends on what they’re struggling with. But the litmus test is: Does it allow my heart to settle? What words would enable that to happen? This can be asked in a therapy session.

The second part is to allow those words to roll through one’s mind, and the word allow is really important. Can you give yourself permission to hear these words inside, over and over again? Because, Lorain, when people feel shame, they mostly feel unworthy of any kind of kindness. So what does it take to receive kindness? What does it take to hear those words and make them land someplace inside, and not just bounce off? Sometimes, if somebody’s really struggling, those words make a person feel worse. So the work is finding just the right words that you can let in and repeat and be nourished by. Those are what we call loving-kindness phrases or self-compassion phrases, and everybody has them. I’ve never found anybody who couldn’t do what I just described.

Lorain Moorehead: Wow. Sometimes it’s easy to tune into the phrasing of the shame part and not be so intentional about the phrasing of the loving-kindness phrase. Like, what words is my shame part telling me?

Dr. Chris Germer: We want to really focus on the resource and on the loving-kindness. The shame will soften.

Core Values as a Red Thread (39:21)

Lorain Moorehead: Can you talk about how values can be connected to the phrase as well?

Dr. Chris Germer: It’s very similar. In the example I just gave, the quintessential self-compassion question is “What do I need?” If you’re suffering or I’m suffering and somebody asks us in a really nice way, “What do you need right now?” you can feel the kindness in it. In a moment of shame, the question becomes “What do I need to hear?”

Core values are similar but different. A core value is beyond us. “What do I need to hear?” is still about me and my suffering, but core values are beyond us. Core values are a red thread that runs through our lives when we’re 30, 40, 50, 60. They may change a little, but mostly not so much. They are the axis around which our world revolves. They’re the direction we go even after other things have been achieved.

So if you want to name your core value, remind yourself of it, and compassionately give yourself what you need because of it, the question is: For me, what is the deepest thing? Another way of saying it is: Whenever I live my life close to this thing, it gives me joy and it gives me energy. When I stray away from it, I feel lost, I feel empty, and I feel tired. What is the quality, not the action, that has been nourishing me, activating me, and giving me joy my whole life? What is the thing that, when I’m doing it, I feel safe?

And the answer is often, “Oh, yeah. For me, the most important thing is connection, to people and to nature.” Or, “The most important thing is honesty,” or authenticity, or love, or compassion, or art. “The most important thing is beauty. When I am living in beauty, everything is right.” “For me, the most important thing is peace.” These are core values. When we know our core values and stick to them, we are never lost.

The other interesting thing about core values, Lorain, is that we can always express them, even in tiny ways, if we are quite compromised or disabled. I had a psychotherapy supervisor, Les Havens, who near the end of his life was in a nursing home with dementia. He was going through the halls saying, “How can I help? How can I help? How can I help?” This man was good to the bone. Even when he was a big-ass Harvard professor, and even when he was in a memory unit, he was living his values. He spent his whole life asking how he could help, in a sense, but doing it with Harvard hubba-hubba. At one point, that was the only thing left.

That’s the whole thing about self-compassion. Thomas Merton said, in essence, if you want to know who I am, don’t ask how I comb my hair. Ask me what I live for, what gets me up in the morning. Nobody can do this for us. If we’re going to be self-compassionate, we have to know our values, commit to our values, and live our values. Otherwise, we’re going to think life gave us a raw deal. Even in a bad situation, we can often squeeze in our core values in some small way.

Values Versus Social Norms (44:10)

Lorain Moorehead: That is such an interesting process in itself, helping folks determine what their values are, looking back on times when they felt in alignment and times when they haven’t, and landing on what the value was. One of the funny things that happens is when they say, “Well, this keeps showing up, but I don’t want that one. I want to have this value.” But the one that keeps showing up is the thread that has pulled through.

Dr. Chris Germer: Such an important inquiry, because a lot of values blend with social norms. If our so-called value is only a social norm and not deeply held, it’s going to deplete us. But if it’s deeply held, even when it isn’t a social norm, it will still energize us and give us joy. For example, somebody might be an artist by nature and grow up in a household of accountants and lawyers and be told, “You can’t be an artist. You’re going to fail.” The world is saying one thing, but one’s deepest promptings are saying something else. We must follow our deepest promptings, not in a way that hurts anybody, but in a way that manifests our uniqueness.

Shame Is Part of Being Human (45:40)

Lorain Moorehead: This has been such an interesting discussion. Is there anything we haven’t talked about that feels important to add?

Dr. Chris Germer: It’s important perhaps to repeat that shame is a part of life. It’s a part of living. It’s perhaps the most difficult emotion because it hurts. It’s also difficult because it makes us disappear, so there’s no one home to work with it. We instinctively want to have nothing to do with shame, but by avoiding shame, it persists and even magnifies. It’s important to know that shame itself is just an emotion that gets its power from avoidance, and that self-compassion allows us to turn toward shame with curiosity and to transform it.

Ultimately, we will never get rid of shame. It’s part of the human condition. It’s even part of just living in duality, the world of pain and pleasure. It’s existential. You can go back to Adam and Eve. But we don’t need to struggle with shame as much as most of us do. In other words, shame is not optional, but the struggle is optional. And we’ve never had, until now, as targeted a treatment for shame as self-compassion. We’ve danced around this for quite some time, but we’ve never had a conceptual model with a host of practical resources that can directly address shame. One of the main reasons I wrote this book, Lorain, is that I’m so excited, particularly about the possibilities for therapists and their clients, to understand that we now have a powerful, targeted treatment for shame, which we did not know before. So we can apply it and see what happens.

Lorain Moorehead: I like the reminder that the strategies aren’t meant to eliminate it, and that the strategies are now available to support ourselves and our clients.

Dr. Chris Germer: To transform it. What we say is to loosen the grip of shame. Shame will never disappear, but usually it has us in a grip, and what we want to do is loosen the grip. The way to do that is to hold ourselves with compassion, and the grip naturally loosens.

Lorain Moorehead: And a reminder too that if a therapist or helping professional listening is able to walk through this process for themselves, their ability to hold that compassion for their clients will increase as well.

Dr. Chris Germer: I really hope that’s how it works. We have to start with our own experience. Then we can see it. When we can see it within, we can see it outside. When people learn about self-compassion for shame, they start to see shame everywhere. That’s not because they’re looking through glasses that have shame on them, but because it is everywhere. Everywhere there is self-criticism, there’s shame. And everywhere there is shame, there is the invitation to kindness.

Where to Learn More (49:27)

Lorain Moorehead: Chris, I’ll link the book. What else would be helpful for people who are curious and want to delve more into this approach?

Dr. Chris Germer: People could go to the Center for Mindful Self-Compassion at centerformsc.org. They have the Self-Compassion for Shame trainings, and people can take the course if they’re interested. People who are already MSC teachers are being trained to teach the Self-Compassion for Shame course all over the world. MSC is taught in 60 different countries, so within the next year or two, wherever people are located, they’ll be able to attend an online course, maybe even an in-person course. But more than anything, I would encourage therapists to explore this for themselves, perhaps even create self-compassion study groups with other people, and really see how this can be brought to bear in clinical work.

Lorain Moorehead: I love it. Thank you so much for your time today. I think this is going to resonate with a lot of folks.

Dr. Chris Germer: Thanks, Lorain. I’m so happy we had this conversation. Really appreciate it.

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

view services

Whether you're a newly licensed therapist seeking foundational support or an experienced practitioner looking to refine your skills, I tailor our supervision to meet your unique professional goals.

Clinical Supervision

view services

I understand that the reality of welcoming a new baby can differ from expectations - whether it's your own feelings, partner support, or overall mood. If you're experiencing postpartum depression, postpartum anxiety, postpartum rage, disconnection, or disappointment despite loving your baby, you're not alone. 

Pregnancy and Postpartum Therapy

WHERE TO NEXT?

view services

In addition to providing EMDR therapy, I'm also an EMDR consultant-in-training, offering consultation services to other EMDR therapists to support their professional development.

EMDR Consultation

listen to podcast

Your dose of clarity, comfort, and actionable advice. Episode 1 is now out!

The Self Careapist podcast

© Lorain Moorehead 2026. All rights reserved. | Privacy policies |

→

@THESELFCAREAPIST

Lorain Moorehead Therapy and Consultation is a Scottsdale-based organization providing online therapy throughout Arizona, Texas, and Alaska and in-person therapy intensives in Scottsdale at 14301 N. 87th St., Scottsdale Arizona 85260. 

Lorain Moorehead

Lorain Moorehead, LCSW, EMDR Certified Consultant, PMH-C, Clinical Supervisor.